First, a bit of background. As a launch promo, Xiaomi offered two models of its phones for the implausibly low price of just £1. This, obviously, is a bargain, and thousands of punters were champing at the bit to get their hands on one.
However, it was unclear how many phones were available for just a quid. On this salient detail, Xiaomi kept shtum.
Although both Gizmodo and Trusted Reviews covered the deal, neither offered any concrete numbers on how much stock was on offer, which suggests that Xiaomi neglected to mention it in the press release. Perhaps that was a deliberate maneuver on Xiaomi’s part because if people knew the truth, there would have been a lot less enthusiasm for the sale.
That’s because according to the promotion’s terms-and-conditions, only three Mi 8 Lite phones were available during the first flash deal. You read that right. Three. Other flash deals only had two units available.
These pocket-money phones were more scarce than gold dust. Or Hamilton tickets. Or Hamilton tickets constructed entirely out of gold dust. That didn’t matter though, as few bothered to read the fine print.
Hundreds — likely thousands — of potential buyers logged on. They registered. They waited with anticipation. And ultimately they were disappointed, as the meager number of handsets sold out in a matter of seconds.
— Christian Cawley (@thegadgetmonkey) November 10, 2018
@xiaomi What a scam.
How many phones did you have on the limited offer?
As soon as the button turned green and you clicked on it it showed sold out. Shame on you.
Xiaomi more like Xiaoscammi.
— Danny Frampton (@dannyframpo) November 10, 2018
@xiaomi UK 1£ event! What a scam! All sold out in less than a second! Wow!
— George Ivanov (@george_i81) November 11, 2018
One user even looked into the site’s code, and found that it was set to show the phone as being sold out as soon as the sale began, without actually checking to see stock levels.
@XiaomiUK_ Your promotion for the £1 phone was a scam. Looking at the logic and browser requests, there are no calls to check stock limits, you simply swap the text to show 'out of stock' once the timer expired. pic.twitter.com/4HxKFENufL
— Phil Williams (@phil_williams81) November 9, 2018
The company later clarified that that the phones would be sold on a lottery basis. Those who clicked the button closest to a pre-defined time will be placed into a pool, with “winners” selected randomly.
Xiaomi had previously made no mention of a lottery, with the legal text for the promotion stating that phones would be sold on a first-come, first-serve basis.
While I’d stop short at accusing Xiaomi of any deliberate wrongdoing (while the site’s source code is certainly fishy, the terms-and-conditions were pretty clear about the number of cheap phones available), I’d certainly say that they’re guilty of stupidity.
You only get one chance at making a first impression, and Xiaomi really could have handled this one better. Given the company is entering a market for the first time, it would have been prudent to avoid doing anything that would engender ill-will or suspicion.
At least their phones are good, eh?
Published November 12, 2018 — 17:17 UTC