The FBI and authorities in New Zealand have suffered a blow in their pursuit of Kim Dotcom and Megaupload, after a New Zealand court ordered them to return his personal data from the service that was seized during raids last year. Furthermore, they must specify exactly what information is at the core of their case against the file-sharing service.
High Court Justice Helen Winkelmann ruled (once again) that the raid on Dotcom’s mansion in January 2012 was illegal due to incorrect warrants. Today, the Justice ordered the national police to return to Megaupload any digital data they possess that is not relevant to the case, as Stuff NZ reports.
Likewise, Justice Winkelmann ordered the FBI to destroy any clones of Megaupload hard drives that contain personal information or other information that are not part of the case. Dotcom and his fellow defendants must be given copies of the hard drives that the US will use to support its case, she ruled.
It’s not clear at this point whether that means regular Megaupload users will be reunited with their data — we reached out to Dotcom to get more details.
A jubilant Dotcom took to Twitter, as ever, to reveal the news:
BREAKING NEWS: High Court: FBI has to return hard drives unlawfully removed from New Zealand + NZ Police has to return my data
— Kim Dotcom (@KimDotcom) May 31, 2013
BREAKING NEWS: Chief High Court Judge rules in our case: “A miscarriage of justice did result.”
— Kim Dotcom (@KimDotcom) May 31, 2013
At the height of its popularity, Megaupload drew 50 million visitors per day and enjoyed the support of a number of high-profile figures within the US music industry. All of that changed, however, when the Department of Justice took the site down in January 2012 for what it described as the largest copyright investigation ever.
The raid on the mansion — footage of which surfaced in August — caused much controversy. Authorities were accused of acting heavy-handedly and, to that point, a helicopter packed with members of New Zealand’s ‘Elite Special Tactics Group’ was used for the raid. Seconds after the helicopter touched down, ground forces arrived in numbers.
According to local news stations, it took 13 minutes for the police to find Dotcom in the ‘Red Room’ of his mansion. Dotcom testified that he was punched, kicked, kneed and otherwise treated unfairly during his arrest, while an unnamed elite police officer reportedly testified that “deliberate force” was applied to Dotcom.
The raid aside, the investigation has suffered a number of high profile issues over the last year or so. Notably, in June 2012, a New Zealand high court ruled that search warrants for the raid were invalid.
In addition to fighting his corner in the Megaupload case, Dotcom is busy running his new business, cloud storage service Mega.co.nz. Dotcom has plans to branch out into email, chat, voice, video and mobile services in the future.
Related read: The life and times of Kim Dotcom
Headline image via Sandra Mu / Getty Images
Get the TNW newsletter
Get the most important tech news in your inbox each week.