This article was published on November 19, 2015

Comcast announces data cap exemption for ‘Stream’ customers, raises net neutrality questions

Comcast announces data cap exemption for ‘Stream’ customers, raises net neutrality questions
Bryan Clark
Story by

Bryan Clark

Former Managing Editor, TNW

Bryan is a freelance journalist. Bryan is a freelance journalist.

Comcast announced today that if you sign up for its $15 streaming service, it won’t count against your data caps.

The service — known as ‘Stream’ — was originally released in the Boston area, but this week the telecom giant also announced its Chicago launch. Seattle is reported to be next, and then a nationwide rollout at some point in early 2016.

The early criticism about the Stream plan, including that from our own commenters on the site and social media, were that the plan was essentially meaningless with Comcast’s data caps. Meaning, one way or another the company could still make up for lost cable revenue even by offering an alternative that appeared to be cord cutter friendly. In this case, instead of ever-increasing cable TV subscription packages, they’d make up the lost revenue through data overages.


It doesn’t appear, for now, that this is the case.

It does, however, raise questions about net neutrality. Giving certain providers preferrential treatment in the terms of free data under the cap exemption while denying this to others goes against the very fiber of net neutrality. That said, there is an exemption for “non-broadband” services or “IP-services that do not travel over broadband Internet access service.”

Comcast is taking full advantage of this distinction.

In a comment to Ars Technica, a Comcast representative said, “No, Stream is an IP cable service delivered over our managed network to the home.”

So, at least in a legal sense, it appears Comcast is in the clear. However, the Federal Communication Commission has the right to review so-called “zero-rating schemes” which results in the commission judging on a case-by-case basis whether this “unreasonably interferes” with the ability of consumers to access some content while being given preferrential service to others.

Whether that review actually happens remains to be seen.

Comcast is Exempting Its New Streaming Service From Usage Caps [DSL Reporters]

Get the TNW newsletter

Get the most important tech news in your inbox each week.

Back to top