It won’t just be an overzealous librarian you have to deal with at the library the next time you need to do some research, you could find yourself at the business end of some heavy handed copyright protection if the UK government have anything to do with it.
The Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS), a ministerial department of the UK Government, have proposed a ruling that could lead to the criminalisation of small businesses, universities, libraries and even neighbours if they operate an open public wireless internet network.
The proposal would be part of the government’s Digital Economy Bill copyright crackdown aimed at cutting internet piracy. It would effectively classify the organisations as copyright infringer’s, the same as an individual subscriber, if copyrighted material was downloaded using their connection.
Penalities could include disconnection from the internet and possible legal action if warnings went unheeded. It is most likely to leave small businesses and public organisations perplexed as to whether they should offer their customers/visitors wireless internet access.
In an interview with ZDNet, Lilian Edwards, Professor of Internet Law at Sheffield University explained that:
“This is going to be a very unfortunate measure for small businesses, particularly in a recession, many of whom are using open free Wi-Fi very effectively as a way to get the punters in. Even if they password protect, they then have two options — to pay someone like The Cloud to manage it for them, or take responsibility themselves for becoming an ISP effectively, and keep records for everyone they assign connections to, which is an impossible burden for a small café.”
The government’s reasoning behind the non-exemption of these particular organisations is that it could open a potential loophole for bogus organisations to register for exemption just to operate as hubs for copyright infringement.
ISP Review highlighted a number of proposals put forward by the Bill which would help an organisation tackle infringement:
- Blocking any software or application downloads onto fixed computer desktops.
- Enabling the privacy/security features of the router, if these are available.
- Installing Firewalls that do not allow access to a number of sites, such as those containing Flash technology.
- Filters to block various sites
- Acceptable conditions of use policy – a “conditions of use” policy, which users have to agree to before getting access to the network, for example no unlawful activity including copyright infringement is permitted.
The report (downloadable here) suggests that the measures aren’t designed to completely eradicate piracy, only make it harder for a network user to engage in copyright infringement.
I can’t remember the last time I infringed copyright by visiting a website that contained Flash, perhaps the government know different.
Here in Italy is has been illegal for a number of years to operate an open wifi without getting authorization and having to log every user. It was done for 'anti terrorism' reasons! Of course it's virtually impossible to enforce, you can site in a cafe in the centre of Milan and pickup at least 3 non protected access points.
Block websites with flash? So that could be every website that has add's on them, I see me not being able to use the internet any longer, If the government are doing this, I hope they plan on enforcing mobile broadband plans on people with unlimited access for free as a alternative, Sounds just as stupid doesn't it.
This law is unlikely to pass, there are dozens of reaaons against, not to mention the lobbying groups. If it does it would mean great business for us.
Keep your network open, just hotspot it. Zonerider
Turns out that Ofcom’s having to crack down on the music companies etc. handing out fines here, there and everywhere.
Actually the DEB’s a good idea but has been badly implemented.
They should have realised the big corporates would abuse their powers sooner or later.
We’ve designed a simple, no-frills wifi service for pubs and bars at public-wifi.co.uk. For a one off cost, the business owner can operate a public wifi hotspot without worry.