The more I use Google’s new social media venture Buzz, the more I feel it should have begun its life as Gmail Labs add-on.
The product just isn’t ready yet and the fact that it’s been thrown into Gmail users lives just-like -that is beginning to feel borderline absurd.
Buzz has potential, there’s no doubt, but Scoble said it perfectly in a comment on his post. He said, ”if you are going to copy another system at least don’t make it worse.” And Buzz currently is a a poor impression of Friendfeed. That’s not to say it will stay that way, but for now at least, this is an alpha product at best.
The tool needs a massive clean up. My fiance’ (a normal, not a geek) took one look at it and called out to me asking how she could turn it off. It’s ugly, and yes that’s fixable but for it to be included as a fully integrated Gmail feature as it is was a bad decision.
Filters and lists. If there’s anything this needs, it’s filters and lists. Frustrating is an understatement and despite rumors that they’re on the way, Buzz should not have been included in Gmail without them.
I could go on but there’s plenty of posts illustrating the frustrations of Buzz and the features it’s missing. One must wonder why Google, normally pretty reserved when it comes to introducing big new features, decided to chuck this one out there. You might consider it an act of desperation. A fear that it if it waited any longer, it might just miss the social networking boat…surely that’s not the case, is it?
It’s probably too late to convert this to a labs feature. Google’s too proud to do that. What it can do however is fix things, the question is how fast.















Google's reaction to some developers
http://www.techeye.net/software/google-begs-dev…
Completely agree. They would have been able to figure out all the privacy issues and provide a more compelling design for everyone if they were able to watch the usage patterns of a smaller percentage of people. As it is, they unnecessarily alienated a LOT of people.
Ultimately it has the potential to be a great product. Obviously Google knows this and I think they just got too excited and jumped the shark.
Why does this article follow days after you guys have promoted the hell out of the service? majority of staff have said its great.. now this makes me think you write what the people want to read.
You think too much.
It certainly will be interesting to watch Buzz grow :-)
I wonder what changes they already have in the pipeline!
Here is a nice model on how to use Google Buzz that you may find interesting… it has some cool tips & tricks
http://www.knowledgegenes.com//home.aspx?kgid=1…
Cheers,
Ollie
Great post Zee, could not agree more with u on this!
Spot on! I don't take lightly being ambushed by a half-assed app when logging into my supposedly secure gmail, and then have to accept it as a permanent fixture. I don't give a rat's rear end what changes Google is planning (or not) to implement, I'm not turning this thing back on. Better luck next time, G
People will whine and cry and be up-at-arms about it, but in the end, Google will fix the problems (like Facebook did with their problems)
I, for one, am happy to see a large company like Google still willing to move quickly, although arguably late, but quickly nonetheless. Yahoo! by comparison had been so conservative in their development that they produced no real innovation, and when they acquired smaller websites they killed the innovation that existed.
Google is a Goliath of a company, that still thinks like a David, and isn't afraid to embrace the “don't worry be crappy” mentality of a start-up. (Guy Kawasaki's quote, btw)