In an interview with Forbes at the Techonomoy conference, Microsoft’s Craig Mundie, the firm’s Chief Research and Strategy Officer, had some harsh words for Apple’s popular Siri feature in its newest phone, the iPhone 4S.
After vamping on the runaway success of the Kinect, and noting that what the company calls ‘natural user interfaces’ are finding traction, Mundie was asked what he thought about Siri. He first noted that it had been marketed effectively, and that “people are infatuated with Apple announcing it.”
But Mundie isn’t impressed with the technology itself, and especially not when compared to what Microsoft’s own Windows Phone platform offers, and has done so since it launched: “At least as a technological capability,” said Mundie, “you could argue that Microsoft has had a similar capability [in Windows Phone] for more than a year.” Fans of Siri would argue that its wider feature set places it apart, but it is impossible to deny that Windows Phone was at least early to the idea.
That of course doesn’t stop Siri from being a whimsical and useful part of the iOS platform. Mundie, however, took the inclusion of Siri as something that Apple employed as a ‘hammer’ to fend off disappointment over the iPhone 4S, which he dismissed as “not a completely new thing.”
It’s always interesting to see what a higher executive of one giant thinks of his competition. Watch the clip, it’s well worth the four minutes:
Sound off in the comments, is Siri such a latecomer?


















The grapes are sour !!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeMicrosoft wrote the book on unimpressive and years late. They make themselves into even bigger asses when they try drag better companies and products down to their level.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeAh, Microsoft.. I remember when Bill Gates gave his impressions of the iPad.. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/04/21/bill-gates-on-the-ipad-it_n_546164.html
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Likemajorace When the ipad launched, it was 'okay'. Now, I would imagine his response is much different (it's only like 70% still just a giant iphone)
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Likeweldon Ok, you're right, iPad (at its release) wasn't that exciting. I actually had the same opinion, more or less, at the release as well.
But I've learned something since then. Visionaries don't evaluate a technology at its inception to the public. They look at what it can do for society in the future, as it -evolves-.
So, yes, Siri can answer questions and give info right now to iPhone users. How about in the future? -Natural Voice AND Contextual Language- technology can be used in so many new ways, even ways we haven't thought about, -outside of smartphone- use.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Like