A court in Milan has convicted three Google Italy executives over an Internet video showing a handicapped teenager being bullied AFP reports.
The video, uploaded on Google Video, where it remained for nearly two months in late 2006, showed four students bullying the teenager with Down’s syndrome in front of more than a dozen others who did not intervene.
The bullies were suspended from their school in Turin, northern Italy, and Google Italy did eventually take down the video nearly two months later but not before the video caused a national outrage.
Due to their delay in action, Milan Judge Oscar Magi ruled that David Drummond, Google’s senior vice president of corporate development, and Peter Fleischer, global privacy counsel, as well as George Reyes, a former chief financial officer, were guilty of the privacy violation charge. The three men were cleared of a defamation charge..
“Google will appeal this astonishing decision” , Google spokesman Bill Echikson said in a statement, adding that the sentence “attacks the principle of freedom of expression”.
“None of these four people had anything to do with the video. They didn’t film it, they didn’t upload it, they didn’t review it. Nonetheless they were held criminally responsible,” Echickson told reporters
“If we are responsible for each vetting, each photo, each video, each posting … then the web as we know it will cease to exist … and the technical benefits will disappear,” Echikson said.















That's bizarre! It's like prosecuting a bus company because someone leaves nasty graffiti on a bus stop.
First China, and now the EU anti-trust investigation and this within a few hours of each other. What's interesting is that Google really is behaving increasingly like a 'meta-state', a kind of online 'country' with its own diplomatic channel via its blogs. What next a private army? :)
You probably don't know that, but Italy is famous for being ridiculous world wide.
Furthermore:
“Italy has one of the lowest levels of press freedom in Europe. A 2009 report by Freedom House classified Italy as “partly free”, one of only two country in western Europe (the second being Turkey), also ranking it behind most former communist states of eastern Europe.[1] Censorship is applied in television such as in press for several reasons.”
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_the_pre…
Italy is a beautiful country filled with stupid people. Oh, by the way, I'm italian.
a few hours? Comparing china with EU is… [fill the blank]
No other company would take two months to act, and no other company avoids talking with everybody else like they do, putting politics and interests above basic humanitarian deeds. This is not about killing google, freedom of expression or the free internet. How come keeping a video about an handicapped kid being bullied, probably published by a teen that doesn't even know how to spell “freedom”, qualifies as breaking freedom of expression?
The web is a place like any other, and guess, what? Google (and others) must comply with laws
a few hours? Comparing china with EU is… [fill the blank]
No other company would take two months to act, and no other company avoids talking with everybody else like they do, putting politics and interests above basic humanitarian deeds. This is not about killing google, freedom of expression or the free internet. How come keeping a video about an handicapped kid being bullied, probably published by a teen that doesn't even know how to spell “freedom”, qualifies as breaking freedom of expression?
The web is a place like any other, and guess, what? Google (and others) must comply with laws
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Oh please, like Google cares about some Kangaroo Italian court! Gimme a break.
jess
http://www.true-privacy.es.tc
Wow…the sentence they've received is just too extreme for the situation. It would warrant a public announcement/apology of some sort…but jail time?
Wow…the sentence they've received is just too extreme for the situation. It would warrant a public announcement/apology of some sort…but jail time?
How so? The internet does not reside in any ONE place, or ONE country, or ONE continent. The internet is the internet. It is global. By enacting/enforcing these so called “laws” on the internet, you are claiming that you have the jurisdiction and the right to police it. You can not police the internet. You can try, and you will fail, as countries have been for over a decade now.
All that Italy has done here is show how naive and utterly foolish they are. I live in the U.S. – so I can technically break Italian internet laws all day and mock them on their own website, with them not being able to do a thing about it. Like I said, you can not police the internet.
Wow, Italy is batshit crazy!
Wow, Italy is batshit crazy!
Maybe the executives of AT&T should go to jail for all those drug deals made over the phone.
simply unbelievable !!!
This is total bs…Talk about freedom.. The US/Google should step in and disallowed this…
Umm…. What were they convicted of? If the video demonstrated how cruel these “people” and the bystanders were, where is the crime???
Awesome. Now kids can bully my son (who has Down Syndrome) without fear of their deeds being captured and posted for others to ID them. I say put the video back up!
wont be using google as my search engine anymore. this is sickening. 2 months to remove that video is 60 days to long. only wish the pieces of human garbage that participated and stood around watching were also being convicted. bet their parents are proud.
I cant believe you have a child with this illness. I wouldnt want my nephew subjected to this behavior and have it put on the internet for the sick people to enjoy seeing it, and doing the same to someone elses child. Grow up and face reality nothing good came out of this.
You said it. You live in the US, you comply with US laws (i hope ;). Google has a company incorporated in Italy.
The internet is everywhere so it doesn't matter, but pedophiles place their servers in some weird offshore platforms … yeah right…
PS: Note that I don't agree with them persecuting individuals
I missed that. now it’s a crime to tell the whole world that there exist impossible people treating handicapped like that? Poor executives. just because there is nobody to blame they instantly became responsible of the clamor. Now who said life is fair?
Its not Google's fault for not vetting the video but it is Google's fault for not acting sooner.
Google provides the medium through which an individual can publicly express themselves. It should be policed by netizens and not by google.
A comparison would be: Passing a physical object (video DVD of the above mentioned abuse) to my viewers in real world, hand to hand, through the air (the medium through which it passes). How can the air be held responsible. Comparing google video to a broadcasting company is a mistake.
This reminds me of the bittorent p2p argument. The tech is being abused for piracy and sudenly people want to ban bittorent.
I don't know how long the people who agree with this ruling have been online but I have been surfing the web since 1996 and I have come to realize that the internet is NOWHERE. The servers are hosted in physical locations yes but the internet is really an abstract. Leave it be and let people alone. If they post something illegal, don't prosecute the virtual real estate owners when they weren't the ones posting it, prosecute the posters…as clearly has been done, already.
Look, if i build a social media website that caters to video and I let people do as they please on it, why should I be held responsible? Likewise, I have an open piece of land that I loan to people to do as they want…someone starts trading illegal goods on it. Why is this my fault?
You are obviously talking about “how it should be”, which is clearly not the case. Comparing google to “air” is hilarious…
The bit torrent argument just proves that the ideology you are claiming doesn't exist or apply to the real world: think napster.
spot on. There may be a distinction between google as an corporate (limited liability) entity and their employees but that's country specific i believe
First some facts!
- The video was online for about two months.
- People sent thousands of requests for removal.
- Google ignored all of them and removed the video only after a police request.
On the other hand, any company can send a DMCA letter for a “supposed” copyright infringement and my blog is taken down immediately.
Copyright more important than personal privacy? Is this the world you want to live in?
Don't call my son ill. He's not sick.