Today, at the Future of Web Design in New York City, Brooklyn based designer and developer Josh Clark took the stage to discuss the 7 Myths of Mobile Web Design.
“Our jobs are getting harder… We’re inundated by all these different screens. But this is also really exciting. How often do new platforms come around?…We’ve got the coolest job in the world. We have to figure out how to use these platforms. It’s one of the most exciting times in the history of our culture.”
-Josh Clark
According to Clark, designers are anthropologists who should view platforms as if they were cultures. So, what makes a mobile culture different from a desktop culture? “We tend to oversimplify mobile needs. And we risk building dumbed down apps that patronize our users,” he says. Designers have lots of mobile mindsets and cultural presumptions. These are the quick takeaways from Clark’s brilliant breakdown:
- Mobile users are rushed and distracted. Wrong. Mobile isn’t just on the go. It’s on the couch, in the kitchen, and during a 3 hour layover. When we’re on mobile, we’re micro-tasking, we’re local and we’re probably bored.
- Mobile=Less. Wrong. Mobile is not less. Mobile is not light. Designers make too many assumptions with screen size. Don’t limit functionality based on-screen size alone. “Saying mobile design should have less is like saying paperbacks have smaller pages, so we should remove chapters,” Clark says.
- Complexity is a dirty word. Wrong. Complexity is awesome, it gives our lives texture. Designers shouldn’t confuse complexity with complication. They need to manage complexity, not kill it. He cites the new Facebook iOS app as a great example of a complex app done well.
- Extra taps and clicks are evil. Wrong. It’s all about Tap Quality > Tap Quantity. Designers can create one big idea per screen instead of one big idea per app. He cites Twitter app’s well designed keyboard that simply slides in and out of view so that secondary tasks are just one tap away.
- Gotta have a mobile website. Wrong. Designers should focus on all platforms. We need great mobile experiences but not necessarily a separate website. Designers shouldn’t think of creating different websites for different devices. They should be thinking, what can the device do to enhance the experience?
“Your mobile site should probably have less stuff than your desktop site right now, not because it’s mobile but because your desktop site is probably full of crap,” he says.
- Mobile is about apps. Wrong. Designers should stop focusing on apps, it’s not sustainable. “We can’t design a new experience on every platform from scratch every time,” he warns. Then, citing Bruce Lee, he says, content is like water; it takes many forms and flows into all these different containers.
- Content and API are for database nerds. Wrong. Designers all have to care about this too and get involved.
In the end, Clark says that designers need to focus on that fact that mobile devices enhance a user’s experience. Mobile is more. It’s a camera, a gyroscope, GPS and voice! Mobile gives a website super powers in comparison to a desktop experience.
What do you think? Is the future of web design most exciting when it comes to mobile? Let us know in the comments.
Featured image: Shutterstock/James Thew
I totally agree especially if you look last couple of years and probably a couple of years from now.
If i'm looking at it a bit from 40,000 feet, the market has evolved, things that were right for a "feature phone" market are no longer correct in the Smartphone era.
The Apps may remain there but the web will take a more prominent position as now (html 5...) technology enables it (more design options), it's easier for developers and going to be easier (and cheaper) for the users.
The competition between devices OS vendors (and we can generalize it to any of the non-PC platforms) creates both improved abilities for the designers/developers. The web/mobile web ecosystem creates a demand from them to do so (and those who lag behind are seeing immediate decline, e.g. RIM). This clearly puts the best platform to best bring it to the users as the browser (and it's evolution).
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeHilarious to read that on a mobile site, that seems to lack soe features. Had to switch to desktop view to comment …
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeMarkus Angermeier this is typical and very understandable: all this crazyness around mobile devices is quite recent, and redoing a whole website take months...
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI love the quote “Your mobile site should probably have less stuff than your desktop site right now... because your desktop site is probably full of crap”, so true. Designers should use mobile as an opportunity (or an excuse to your client) to really focus on the goals of a site, such as content, instead of "making the logo bigger" or packing every pixel full of calls-to-action.
The medium really allows us to cut the fat that very often is taken out of our control.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI agree. "Designers should stop focusing on apps"
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI want to +1 this but I can't :/
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeThis phrase is the key: "Designers shouldn’t think of creating different websites for different devices. They should be thinking, what can the device do to enhance the experience?".
So true! The success of a site will come from how much it can get out of the device it's viewed on.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeConversation from Twitter
larakoch Thanks for the RT!
thebobstercom Thanks for the RT! It's a pretty good article.
Conversation from Facebook
Nothing bugs me more than being forced into a crappy mobile experience (by browser detection) and not being able to "switch to desktop version. Agree strongly:esigners should stop focusing on apps, it’s not sustainable. “We can’t design a new experience on every platform from scratch every time,” he warns.... content is like water; it takes many forms and flows into all these different containers."