When Google issued its “Stop censoring us or we quit your country” announcement, it was a bold and unexpected move. So, how have the Chinese responded?
Never before has a major US corporation stood up to the potential moneypit that is China. Yes, everyone knows about the human rights violations and the restrictions of free speech, but when there’s so much potential profit to be made in China, the West has generally put all that to the back of their mind.
Now Google has said “Change or we’re out of here” it’s worth looking at the Chinese reaction. There hasn’t been a great deal yet, but here’s some of what’s out there.
Although there has been no official word from the Chinese government, an un-named official from China’s State Council Information Office has said in a phone interview reported by China Daily that the government has sought more details from Google about its announcement but that aside from that “It is still hard to say whether Google will quit China or not. Nobody knows.”.
Meanwhile, Google’s Chinese staff are in a state of confusion. The same China Daily report quotes an employee as saying “We were told that Google might quit China at a general meeting on Wednesday morning, and all of us feel very sad”. You’ve got to feel for them – being told your job is a pawn in a political game must be pretty crushing.
Elsewhere, a blog supposedly belonging to the chief architect of Chinese search engine giant Baidu criticised Google’s move. The BBC reports that the post said “What Google said makes me sick. If you are to quit for the sake of financial interest, then just say it.”
However, since then it appears the post in question has been removed with one in its place stating that his views are not those of Baidu as a company. Rough translation (ironically from Google) of the replacement post here.















The interesting thing here is also watching the relative share prices of Google and Baidu. If you ignore the fact the US market has had a bad week, brining most stocks down in price you will note that Baidu is loving this news. The overnight price for Baidu (Ticker BIDU) has leapt 16% or $63 per share on this news (closed at $386 on the Nasdaq last night) – Google is trading down 2% or $12 from its closing price of $590.
The markets open in half an hour and it will be interesting to see how this plays out. If Google does pull out, then Baidu is laughing [despite the recent hack attempt http://thenextweb.com/asia/2010/01/12/breaking-baidu-hacked-iranian/.
Time will tell.
How could this have been for the sake of Google’s financial interest? Google stands to lose money from this, not gain.
to brad. Financial intrest in the negative sense: What he is implying is that google is leaving because they can’t take the competition.
A political game? Why?
Google is just true to there corporate motto.
I for one respect there decision.
Google didn’t threaten to leave China because of censorship,they’re threatening to leave because of Chinese hackers trying to steal information and personal detais about human rights advocates.
In other words, the Chinese Communist government is trying to hack into Google – like they have with MANY western firms – to steal information about HRA’s, so they can find them, jail them, or kill them.
But what’s a few dozen dead activists, go to Wal-mart and buy more Chinese crap and support the tyrants.
Right?
The odd thing is this morning, it looks like someone in China took another shot at Google by hacking google maps. I have a screenshot of it.
http://www.perivision.net/wordpress/?p=2545
what a fuck. hacking? the software is facing hackers all the day and it's too normal to the internet world. Goolge is jsut playing politic games. As a Chinese, I don't care if Goolge leave or not. But I think Google is just an internet engine, would it bother our politics, our governments, our people, our rights. We are different, we have our way to control our country, we have our way to live. And alos the Google has not reslove its infringement event and just leaves, so is Google responsible? Google's leave also affect the gmail users and Google Doc, we lose lots of materials. Who will be responsible for that? If Google wants to leave, please just leave, and please don't try to make the whole world believe China is ugly. Plese leave us alone.