The party is ON! Join us at TNW Conference 2021 in Amsterdam for face-to-face business!

The heart of tech

This article was published on January 17, 2017

    Video games risk lawsuits by using the ‘Red Cross’ sign for health packs

    Video games risk lawsuits by using the ‘Red Cross’ sign for health packs
    Mix
    Story by

    Mix

    Former TNW Writer

    Mix is a tech writer based in Amsterdam that loves cinema and probably hates the movies that you like. Tell him everything you despise about Mix is a tech writer based in Amsterdam that loves cinema and probably hates the movies that you like. Tell him everything you despise about his work on Twitter.

    Working on their incarceration simulator Prison Architect, co-creators Mark Morris and Chris Delay ran into an unexpected legal trouble when the British Red Cross organisation emailed them with the perplexing notice that their game had breached the laws of the Geneva Conventions Act from 1957.

    As bizarre as it might sound, the two developers had apparently used an internationally protected sign without realizing it’s not free to use. The symbol in question? A five-pixel wide red cross displayed on ambulances inside the game.

    While this might seem like a silly violation, PC Gamer explains the iconic symbol doesn’t belong to the public domain, but instead is the property of the International Committee of the Red Cross, which reserves the right to protect the sign from any acts the institution deems as misuse.

    Though initially Morris and Delay thought someone was playing a prank on them and their company, Introversion Software, the email turned out to be absolutely legitimate. It also meant the company had been breaking the law for years.

    As the email informed:

    If the red cross emblem or similar signs are used for other purposes, no matter how beneficial or inconsequential they may seem, the special significance of the emblem will be diminished.

    The red cross emblem or similar designs are not general signs of ambulances, health care, first aid, the nursing or medical profession, or similar matters. Moreover, they are not signs to be used for commercial purposes, such as for advertising campaigns or on products.

    Morris and Delay have since gone on to adjust all instances of the red cross emblem in Prison Architect as to avoid potential legal issues, but they’re hardly the only ones to have done so.

    As you can observe in the feature image, smash-hit game Halo too decided to silently move away from using the red cross sign, replacing it with a simple ‘H’ instead.

    In a similar fashion, years ago Japanese toy-maker Takara opted to refrain from using a plain red cross emblem when working on its Transformers Masterpiece series, re-sketching their designs to resemble the trademarked symbol less.

    Credit: Takara

    Introversion Software has uploaded a video on YouTube where Morris and Delay have summed up their peculiar story. Watch the clip below to get their perspective on the full story.

    via Kotaku