Join us at TNW Conference 2022 for insights into the future of tech →

The heart of tech

This article was published on March 24, 2016

Aggregators like Google News could be kicked out of Europe

Aggregators like Google News could be kicked out of Europe
Kirsty Styles
Story by

Kirsty Styles

Reporter

Kirsty Styles is a journalist who lives in Hackney. She was previously editor at Tech City News and is now a reporter at The Next Web. She l Kirsty Styles is a journalist who lives in Hackney. She was previously editor at Tech City News and is now a reporter at The Next Web. She loves tech for good, cleantech, edtech, assistive tech, politech (?), diversity in tech.

European lawmakers are considering a Europe-wide “Google tax” requiring search engines to pay publishers for linking to and using “snippets” of their work.

Trouble is, the idea has already been tried in Spain and Google simply closed its News service in the country, leading to a significant drop in traffic for publishers.

Another version of it is already live in Germany too and publishers ended up simply giving Google a licence to link to their work.

This new proposal is all part of the European Commission’s plan for the Digital Single Market, designed to “create better access for consumers and businesses to digital goods and services across Europe; setting the right conditions for digital networks and innovative services to flourish and maximise the potential of the digital economy.”

And while this might sound like a stellar plan to get paid, many publishers actually disagree with the idea.

“As publishers, we know such proposals make it harder for us to be heard, to reach new readers and new audiences. They create new barriers between us and our readers, new barriers to entry for news publishers such as ourselves,” a consortium of European publishers said in an open letter in December.

“It will be harder for us to be present, discovered and accessed by our readers online. It will be harder for our readers to engage with our stories online, to share links or our headlines with their friends. It will be harder for us to grow, develop new sources of information and innovate in our business.

“Incredibly, in Spain, we are deprived of control over our own content, since we are not allowed to disseminate our news without payment, whether we like it or not.”

The Commission is seeking public contributions on the proposal right now, despite the fact that the European Parliament has rejected the idea too.

A campaign, Save The Link, has been created to help people quickly register their responses.

It says: “Outdated media publishers are successfully lobbying all over the world to restrict linking on the Internet. Spain and Germany have recently changed their laws to apply charges to link to news websites.

“Independent news media and bloggers can’t do their jobs, aggregators are struggling, small presses find their websites unlisted, and access to knowledge is restricted. Now, old media firms have been pressuring lawmakers to apply link censorship laws to the whole EU.”

News aggregators, whether Twitter or Digg, simply make it easier for you to curate your daily news. Watch out, though, the EU and its army of publishing giants is coming for them.

➤ Commission seeks views on neighbouring rights and panorama exception in EU copyright [EU Commission via ArsTechnica]