The heart of tech is coming to the heart of the Mediterranean. Join TNW in València this March 🇪🇸

This article was published on August 31, 2012

If Amazon sold 5 million Kindle Fires in 9 months, the Kindle Fire 2’s job could be a nightmare

If Amazon sold 5 million Kindle Fires in 9 months, the Kindle Fire 2’s job could be a nightmare
Emil Protalinski
Story by

Emil Protalinski

Emil was a reporter for The Next Web between 2012 and 2014. Over the years, he has covered the tech industry for multiple publications, incl Emil was a reporter for The Next Web between 2012 and 2014. Over the years, he has covered the tech industry for multiple publications, including Ars Technica, Neowin, TechSpot, ZDNet, and CNET. Stay in touch via Facebook, Twitter, and Google+.

Amazon this week announced its Kindle Fire tablet has “Sold Out” after first going on sale on November 15 in the US. The company also revealed the device was its most successful product launch in the history of the American retail website. Unsurprisingly, Amazon didn’t release sales figures, but it did note that the Kindle Fire “captured 22% of tablet sales in the US.”

Asymco’s Horace Dediu has taken that number, did some quick calculations, and extrapolated a much more useful raw number. The math is fairly straightforward:

The challenge becomes knowing how many total tablets were sold in the US during this time frame.

Fortunately we know the vast bulk of that total based on the Samsung v. Apple trial. Both Apple and Samsung submitted as evidence sales of the iPad and the Tab product lines in the US. The iPad added up to 16.14 million units (Q4’11 through Q2’12) and the Tab was 540k units. That makes the iPad and the Tab add up to about 16.7 million units. Assuming an additional 1 million units for the other (non-Kindle) total yields an estimate of 22.7 million tablet devices sold in the nine months ending June.

Applying the 22% claim to that total gives a Kindle sales total of 4.987 million. That’s awfully close to a round number of 5 million.

A few points need to be made here. First, the two numbers provided by Apple and Samsung are likely very accurate, given that they had to be provided in court. Next, the 1 million ballpark number: a few months ago I would have said it’s a gross overestimate, but the recently-released Nexus 7 might skew that and actually make it an underestimate. Still, taking into account the Galaxy Tab’s numbers, and that the Nexus 7 has only been on sale for about a month, I think Dediu’s 5 million sales number for the Kindle Fire is a pretty fair estimate.

So, is this a big deal? Does 5 million sales mean the Kindle Fire has been disrupting the market? Dediu doesn’t think so, pointing to the Kindle Fire’s prominent placement on, its loss-leading pricing, and that the success has largely been a US-only phenomenon.

I have to disagree, but I also think the tide’s about to turn. Given how Android tablets have been selling thus far, the Kindle Fire is an immense success. Grabbing a fifth of the sales pie is phenomenal. Remember: Amazon didn’t have any experience building a full-fledged tablet. The Kindle work certainly helped, of course, as did being the world’s largest online retailer.

In fact, I’ve long believed that the Kindle and Kindle Fire has been the only strategy that could possibly disrupt the tablet market that Apple controls so well. The Samsung Galaxy Tab sales, which were the highest for a long time in the Android division, were a perfect example as to why.

Everything changed two months ago with the launch of the $199 Nexus 7. Suddenly Google had a product that was not only significantly superior to the Kindle Fire, but it matched Amazon’s price. Amazon would not have hit 5 million sales if the Nexus 7 arrived on the scene sooner.

Amazon has something up its sleeve for September 6. In my mind, the Kindle Fire 2 will be awesome, but it won’t be enough. Don’t get me wrong; Amazon will continue to sell Kindles and Kindle Fires at an impressive pace. The company will likely continue slashing their prices and making the devices more and more irresistible.

The problem is that Amazon now has a real competitor on its hands. Google is the world’s most popular search engine — not just for the US — and like Amazon, it’s not afraid to use that to its advantage.

The iPad doesn’t count as a competitor to the Kindle Fire because Apple currently dominates the high-end tablet market and simply can’t compete, or at least doesn’t want to compete, on price. With the rumored iPad mini though, that could all change.

So the Kindle Fire 2 is going to have an even tougher job than its predecessor: instead of no real competitors, it will likely have two very solid competitors. Amazon better have something great planned, or the Kindle Fire will go from the disruptor to the disrupted.

See also: Amazon goes with Nokia instead of Google for new Kindle Fire maps

Image credit: stock.xchng

Also tagged with