I’m at the London Web Summit today and it’s set to be a packed event full of UK-centric discussion, from whether or not the Government should be helping startups to a panel that our own Robin Wauters is hosting about the future of our digital money.
I too am wrangling industry leaders into a discussion about the future of local, mobile and social business.
“The most awesome stage”
Last year, Facebook's VP of Design thought the TNW Conference main stage was the best she'd ever been on.
At the moment it seems that we are still far from a smooth process for getting the information we want, when we want it, wherever we are. Data charges, battery life and finding a signal are the base line for growth in this area, but there is still a lot to discuss when it comes to arranging plans for the near future.
I asked three of the panelists to talk to me ahead of the event in order understand their thoughts on the subject.
Omid Ashtari is the Business Development Director at Foursquare and he is very aware of the current limitations. “In many ways, precise always-on location awareness from a device perspective drains a lot of battery. That will change with upcoming generations of phones obviously but currently it’s a trade-off. Do I want really relevant local coupons or battery time?”
In your neighbourhood
One of the problems with a mobile business strategy while the market is still evolving is that it can be very expensive to be local as well as mobile.
Glenn Shoosmith is the Founder and CEO of Booking Bug and he believes we still have a long way to go yet, “The thing about hyperlocal sites and mobile is that the adoption rate is still very slow. While we might be ahead of the curve, there are still relatively few people actually using it. Local businesses would be smart to wait and see how the market develops and then try it when the adoption rate is higher and the costs are lower.”
Helpful or creepy?
Another issue for mobile advertising and incentive is the ability for it to spook users. It’s one thing to be able to find helpful information when you need it, but another when it is sent to you.
Mark Read is Strategy Director and CEO of WPP Digital, and he understands that the audience may not yet be ready for push notifications that seem a bit personal, “Facebook does a good job for social marketing, but it really depends on if it is an interruption. For now TV and radio are fine, but nobody really wants a pushed SMS sent to their phone. It’s intrusive.
“To make social advertising work, it really has to be compelling. When you add this to local and mobile, there is a fine balance between spooky and relevant.”
It’s probably not surprising that Ashtari of Foursquare thinks otherwise and visualises a different scenario, “I live in London and let’s say I might find myself in Paris one morning. Foursquare would realize I am outside my usual environment. It would also know that I usually check into a particular food chain in the morning, so it try to look for a sandwich place for me.
“On the other side is a national fast food chain that is willing to give discounts to people who are more likely to convert to paying or loyal customers. So my phone buzzes and I get a notification from them for 2 euros off the breakfast meal.”
That sounds pretty useful, but are we all ready for our mobile devices to tell advertisers where we are and what we might like? The relevance of targeted advertising is key when it comes to convincing paying customers that they are getting what they need and not just being stalked.
Shoosmith says that in fact we have always been targeted, but it’s a matter of choice, “Advertising has always been targeted. When you make your choice to buy your newspaper, you choose to see their adverts too. When you watch (TV talent show) The X Factor, you choose to also see the adverts that are appropriate for that program. People agree to targeted advertising but they don’t like it to be obvious. That’s the strange thing.
“Google already provides emails with adverts and they know so much about us. But we are happy to put up with that when it provides an email service for free, it’s the same with Facebook. The rewards mechanism is a way of making advertising and data gathering acceptable, it works because you get something back.”
So it seems that the trick to getting a mobile strategy together could be to wait for bigger businesses to make the first mistakes, watch the market settle and then offer something so nice that your customers won’t mind a little intrusion.
No doubt more issues will come from the panel discussion, but for now, are you ready for your phone to reveal your location and offer you a cheaper sandwich?