The Next Web

The dark side of Twitter lists

The dark side of Twitter listsMichael Gray, a social media and search engine optimization consultant, conducted an interesting experiment:

The question he tried to answer: Understanding that Google’s page rank algorithm incorporates the value of site A linking to site B, could the fact that Twitter.com’s new list feature lets users create arbitrary lists with free text descriptions expose the potential to damage somebody’s reputation?

Given that Twitter.com enjoys an extremely high page rank value, what would happen, if e.g. one creates a list titled “people who bought links” and just put a randomly selected Twitter user on it?

Well, that’s exactly what Michael did.

The list he created is here. Now, if you do a Google search for “people who bought links” his list shows up as the very first result revealing Matt Cutts, the poor Twitter user who ended up being on that list. It took only two days for Michael’s list to the top of Google’s results.

We’d like to reemphasize that Matt Cutts never bought links, though, as Michael clearly outlines in his related blog post.

Gray provides a list of recommendations you might want to follow, if you’re an avid Twitter user:

  • Monitor what lists you are on regularly. If something bad pops up, take steps to correct it before it’s too late.
  • If you see this being abused, let a search engine representative know. Don’t expect them to take it down, but the sooner they see it being abused the sooner they will work to combat it.
  • If you run a site that facilitates user generated content, be on the lookout for how people can abuse your system. The last thing you want is to end up with a  squidoo spam problem and have the search engines take action against you.

Have you checked lists you’re on?

Tags:  

  • Matt could easily remove himself from this list INSTANTLY by blocking the person who put him on that list.
  • Sure, if Matt a) knows that this is the way out of a list and b) checks his listings regularly. Do you check the 5.325 lists you're on? :-)
  • Actually I do. Why? I care about my reputation.
  • Using any tools for it? Any recommendation?
  • Apparently you have a lot more free time than most of us.
  • As a much less popular person, I am glad to not have this problem.
  • John
    I used a program called autotweeter which can send automatic updates to twitter from my desktop.It is very good and I purchased the full version for 20 bucks..When I asked them they said the coming version will include twitter lists too..that you be great.Anyways here is the link for it.

    http://www.autotweeter.in
  • andrew spooner
    to be honest if someone puts me on a list called "braindeadsickpeople" because of my left-leaning political views (as happened recently) i consider it libelous.

    As twitter are, in effect, the publisher they have responsibility.

    Of course the argument goes "well block them then."

    I was on the road in a remote area of developing country when this happened. I am assuming this libel was up for several days before I blocked it.

    As you all know several days is millenia in the online world.

    If twitter dont have the balls to control lists they should bin it.

    Or they could end up on the receiving end of some pretty sharp law suits.
  • You might want to familiarize yourself with the definition of libel. Twitter has zero responsibility in actual cases of libel either, anymore than the owner of this website does if someone posted a libelous comment about you.
  • Chances are if someone put you on a "bad" list, you probably are a "bad" person. Justsayin.
  • Justin Parks
    Interesting experiment. I think 99 percent of folks would NOT be aware that blocking a person will remove them from that persons lists.

    Of course, this experiment also shows the power behind lists in ranking for positive terms that you do wish to be associated with.

    It also leaves accounts that run spam or which are automated wide open for some serious slapping as well.

    Oh the joy...
  • Wow, thats a really interesting article. So far the best content i read for today!

    Thanks again for posting this up.

    Dino | Dinono.com
  • Thanks for your kind words, Dino. We try our best to bring to you a wide variety of topics, perspectives and culture.
  • I do also monitor the lists I'm on, I think they are really funny sometimes.. people list me as a "dear friend" when I've never even tweeted with them. I also have a google alert set up for my name and company name so that anytime it hits google I know about it immediately. I advice my web clients to do the same... Your reputation online can and will make you or break you.
  • There's a new service recently launched but not widely reported. It's called List Watcher. Follow them and it will DM you when you get added to or removed from a List, which is how I found myself to be on a friends "buddies" List.

    http://twitter.com/listwatcher
blog comments powered by Disqus
 


TwitterCounter