Has Facebook given up on location-based services or are they preparing something truly new?
An announcement posted to Facebook’s official blog today briefly mentions editing the site’s terms and conditions to account for a change in a future location feature. Rather than potentially allowing users to geotag posts (like any of a number of social networks), Facebook suggests that they’re going to adopt the concept of a “place,” such as a business’ fan page. Facebook asserts that this is a novel approach to location.
Is it really that novel, though?
Sure, it will certainly provide users of the service an increased amount of information about the places their friends are visiting. The question is, simply put, is this service really that much different from Google Buzz’s location services? The answer appears to be a little murky.
While the “places” concept has an interesting slew of uses, such as potentially blocking location data in sensitive places (home, office, etc.), it also seems geared towards providing more targeted advertising than is already available on the site. Since advertisers can purchase ads geared towards users based on age, network and other personal factors, this seems like a logical next step. By providing incredibly focused advertisements, such as giving restaurant patrons checking their Facebook ads for the ice cream place next door, Facebook hopes to be able to charge advertisers even more steeply.
By doing so, Facebook could run roughshod over privacy. Sure, location-based services have progressively been moving towards these hyper-focused ads, but that doesn’t make their arrival any less concerning. If Facebook keeps its current opt-out sharing model, less-savvy users will inevitably share more than they’d like to. While some users are okay with spreading their location data all over the web, many of us want some parts of our lives to remain our business alone.















Facebook is probably smart to rethink this…
Facebook / Mark Zuckerman is surely going to monetize the hell out of this while remaining 'concerned about your privacy'. Its a shame that the people who are less digitally inclined are actually having to work to figure out how to keep their information private in a system that was previously closed. The smacks of corporate irresponsibility in my mind; putting monetization above user's privacy concerns.
I'm not feeling the location craze. I was interested at first, but not now. It's compelling at first but quickly looses its appeal when we start to realize the broader implications in using it.
The entire world does not need to know where I am in real-time. Honestly, it wouldn't be that interesting to know. There's three main groups of people that I see ruining this game for everyone. Creeps, thieves and advertisers. Damn them. But they'll always be around.
Check-ins and geolocation-enabled everything a fun idea in theory and much can be monetized around it…I just think that we may have hit a wall here in terms of reasonable privacy. Just one man's opinion.
-@JoshuaGuffey
Good article.
I think that FaceBook (and Twitter, etc, etc) are going to struggle in the geolocation front.
Just as the big social media sites are now huge funnels to and from other 'information/news” sites and content sources, YouTube, etc, they are possibly doomed to be just reading destinations for the geolocation mobs.
FourSquare would be the leader of the pack in this. It and the other geo-social sites will rule this space and I think that FaceBook and Twitter might just have to get their chequebooks out if they want to play
The things that they all need to do more work on is integration (and @anywhere and the newly suggested FaceBook tweeks on “connect” are in the direction) and smarter ways to share the money
Jimi Bostock
PUSH Agency
Brisbane | Canberra | Sydney | Australia
jimi@pushagency.net
Hey Josh, I think that teh FourSqaure model of geolocation is probably what will bridge the gap between your rightly put concerns and the organic and growing desire for people to be part of the feedback loop
Jimi Bostock
PUSH Agency
Brisbane | Canberra | Sydney | Australia
jimi@pushagency.net