Yes, yes, yes – this is the year of Smart TV – it’s all potentially very interesting, and our viewing experiences could be transformed forever, but it’s going to get very tedious before it becomes truly exciting.
Looking at some of the news we’ve seen this week so far: Samsung is opening an API for its TVs; Myspace is reinventing itself as a social TV service; Google TV is getting new hardware and a revamp; Ubuntu is entering the TV space; Opera is launching a TV app store; UK broadcaster BSkyB has invested in innovative social TV app Zeebox and aims to integrate its features into its own apps…
Expect the Smart TV buzz to build further as talk of an Apple TV set mounts throughout the year.
This is the latest frontier in the world of technology – TVs that allow us to be more interactive, to watch what we want, when we want. The problem is that this is just like the Wild West: while many settlements were successfully built, there were plenty of casualties along the way. We’re going to see a lot of failures in the Smart TV arena – many of services we’ll see this year will go nowhere.
This is unavoidable, of course – every technology has its period of trial and error where manufacturers and consumers work out together what is the best mutual approach. Sometimes superior technology loses out to better marketing, but in the end we tend to reach a consensus over which technologies are the ones consumers should invest their hard-earned money in.
The problem is that right now ‘Smart TV’ is such a buzz phrase that a lot of consumers are going to get burned by buying set-top boxes or TVs with ‘smart’ technology that could be dead in the water in a year’s time. There’s no way of knowing which technology will be successful and which will fail – it’s like Blu-ray versus HD DVD all over again but with many more contenders. We won’t have an overall winner this time, but there will be many casualties. Prepare for at least a year of confusing and noisy marketing, inflated claims and hype in the meantime.
I’m highly excited about the potential of Smart TV, but for now I feel like putting my fingers in my ears and ignoring it for a year until it shakes itself out.


















this is pretty weird...maybe people who like this will also like the Smart Goggles: http://wp.me/p20yRJ-gi
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeTotally agreed. I've been using an Apple TV since the start of 2007 for all of my television viewing and I haven't seen anything between 2007 and this CES just gone that remotely piques my interest over the existing setup. These companies have been sitting on their laurels since 2007 and now that they've decided to do something their offerings are lackluster.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI've never purchased a TV. I'm on my second tube TV. A nice new TV would be great, but that's not where I can really spend my money right now. What about how new tech markets effect the bargain markets? The more people move to the next-gen Smart and 3D TV, the more higher-quality TVs enter the free/bargain market, correct? Where will that line be moved this year? :)
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeBut I agree, there will only be a few format-controlling winners (and iOS and Android they will be). Other than having to make a choice at purchase time, it won't affect most users who will only experience the difference as slightly different fonts and release dates, and a different remote layout.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeWell, this has been playing out since the first interactive TV platforms in the mid 90s. What will happen will be decided by the interplay between traditional content makers and those adding application layers on top of/with programming - and how the revenue or investment will work. Thousands of great ideas for iTV never happened because there wasn't the investment ready, or acceptance that it would be a widely adopted thing. That turned out to be true - only now do we really have credible platforms (most iTV hardware devices could either pull a jpeg out of a muxed stream, or play the video - but not both at once, hence it's relegation to an updated ceefax that felt more like an offline web than boundary-breaking platform).
But much as apps have diminished the role of the phone on smartphones, apps will diminish the role of consumption of linear media on TV, and almost certainly subsume the role of dedicated games systems. Disc-based media will go the way of vinyl - cranky collectors and packaging fetishists only. The lifespan of each new disc-based medium is always far lower than those it replaced.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeTo many, it's all completely superfluous. If I want to watch something on demand I'll just download it, put it on a memory stick and play it through my Xbox 360. Eliminating that tiny bit of hassle is worth about £1 (a week, not per show...) to me. If I can get Smart TV for that much, I'll start listening. Until then, I'll leave it.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeStu Bradley Presuming you can get your Xbox on your home network, you should be able to eliminate the memory stick and stream from Windows Media Player without spending anything extra. If you've got an older 360 without built-in wifi you can just pick up a $100 AirPort Express (I'm sure there are cheaper non-Apple options but I'm a Mac guy so I don't know) and you're all set for on-demand streaming from your PC.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeJoel Falconer Hey thanks for that man, unfortunately I do have a 360 without built in wifi AND I currently don't have a home network with a router etc (dongle internet, what a draaag). If I upgrade all that, I'll def check that out!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeStu Bradley That's rough! I don't know what dongle Internet is like outside of Australia but it's horrible here :P
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeJoel Falconer It's not perfect but it's gets me by and it's cheap, I just do all my big downloads during the day on a better network!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Like