The Next Web

How to paint a gray picture of China

By Ernst-Jan Pfauth on November 13, 2008


I’m touring around China with bloggers. I hope to give you as many updates as possible about this land of endless opportunities. Thanks to Spil Games for sponsoring me.

During this China 2.0 week, a rather large group of Beijing bloggers gathered in the Blue Frog, an American haven in China’s capital with excellent wifi. During a square (as in not round) table discussion about business 2.0 and outsourcing, tweets were pumped onto the web. The hashtag “china20” even ranked no. 1 trending topic at some point. The part of this discussion which interested me the most was the annoyance of Chinese bloggers about us, the western ones. The issue: we don’t paint a gray picture of China.

How to paint a gray picture of China

“Bloggers who speak little or no Chinese do lousy research”, complained Brendan O’Kane. “They find one English-writing blogger from China and project his beliefs and writings on all Chinese bloggers. Hence our image of being online nationalists”.

Richard from Peking Duck agrees with Brendan, but also admits he used to do the same when he started blogging back in 2002. “My blog used to be a wealth of misconceptions, a mess full of prejudice. Now I know better.”

“When my favorite bloggers from abroad address China, even the most liberal ones paint a black and white picture,” said Richard, concerning reports about human rights and censorship.” It’s actually pervasive in all western media”.

How to paint a gray picture of China
Brendan O’Kane

After hearing these complaints, I asked the two gentleman how we could paint a gray picture of the country they reside in. “Read lots of blogs about China to broaden your view”, said Brendan. “Try Fool’s Mountain“. Richard added that Peter Hessler from The New Yorker also writes interesting pieces about China.

I’d like to add that Brendan’s and Richard’s blog are also worth reading. They both have a sharp pen and use it to publicize their refreshing thoughts.

Photo credits: CN Reviews

Ernst-Jan Pfauth editor in chief
Ernst-Jan is blogger and co-organizer of BLOG08, who previously worked in New York to cover news at the United Nations. Next to writing, he's also a singer in the band Christina Five. Follow him on Twitter or read his personal blog Dutchproblogger.com .
4 Responses to “How to paint a gray picture of China”
  1. [...] and find an additional post from the perspective of China 2.0 Tour participant Ernst-Jan Pfauth here. You can find all of the recorded shows and all upcoming shows to be streamed live here: [...]

  2. [...] – How to paint a gray picture of China China really is very complex, and most descriptions don’t do it [...]

  3. [...] frustrations of those who have a foot in both China and the West–that most Western observers paint a black and white picture of China that lacks the nuanced grays required to truly explain the dynamics in China.  He then applies this toward helping the Western [...]

  4. Anonymous says:

    House//no666 rashid khan gunj gate peshawar
    Ilove art attack I aiways see art attack it is a lovely program

    To NEIL

    FROM
    MAHNOOR AND RABIYA




Meta

Short URL for this post:

Tip Techmeme, submit to Hackernews or upload an avatar.


Comment

NEW! Now available in local languages too!
Blog network:
 
TwitterCounter